Mulligan's Pie Shop's Pies
Signature Items
Signature Apple Pie
25
A mixture of tart and sweet apples, thinly slices, perfectly spiced, baked in a flaky golden scratch made crust. Baked with a full top crust. Decorative crusts available, charges may apply.
Signature Pie Bites
15 per dozen
Scratch-made pies, but in miniature. Topped with homemade whipped cream and decorated based on flavor. Roughly the size of a mini muffin. Sold by the dozen.
*Limit 1 flavor per dozen*
Decorative Crusts
30
Custom designs for any occasion! Adorable shapes or vibrant colors are available to make your special design come to life.
Fruit Pies
Top sellers: Apple, Rhubarb, Blueberry, Peach, and Cherry. Flavors may be limited by fruit availability or quality.
Double Crust
25
Scratch made fruit filling sealed in a full top crust (also known as two crust pie)
Lattice Crust
25
Classic pie crust in a woven pattern
Filled Pies
Custards, creams, mousses, and more!
Coconut Cream Pie
25
Extra crispy crust, scratch-made filling, topped with coconut infused whipped cream, sprinkled with toasted coconut
Chocolate Mousse
25
Signature crust filled with homemade chocolate mousse, topped with whipped cream, decorated with chocolate cookies. *cookie crust pictured*
Peanut Butter Mousse
25
Signature crust filled with homemade peanut butter mousse, topped with vanilla whipped cream, decorated with peanut butter chips or sprinkles. *cookie crust pictured*
Banana Cream
25
Classic flaky crust with a generous layer of bananas, filled with chocolate cream (pictured) or vanilla cream, then another layer of bananas, topped with whipped cream (not pictured)
Key Lime
25
Homemade graham cracker crust, filled with scratch-made key lime filling, topped with fluffy whipped cream
Pecan Pie
25
Signature crust filled with a classic nutty, sugary, gooey filling
Crust Options
Signature crust comes standard on most pies. Other crust options by request. Gluten-free options available.
Signature Scratch-made Crust
Traditional flaky, golden, buttery pie crust. Made to order, all by hand. Comes standard on most pies. Other crusts by request.
Gluten-free option based on availability. Gluten-Free Pie Bites available as well!
Chocolate Cookie Crust
+additional cost
America's favorite cookie in a crust. Pairs well with chocolate mousse and peanut butter mousse!
Gluten-free option based on availability.
*Not available for pie bites*
Graham Cracker Crust
+additional cost
Classic graham cracker crust. Pairs well with lemon meringue or peanut butter mousse!
Gluten-free option based on availability.
*Not available for pie bites*
Prices subject to change. Last updated 01/14/2025.